Over on the Trumpet Players International Network (TPIN) mailing list there is a discussion taking place about the demise of the grand cornet solos as so perfectly recorded by Wynton Marsalis on his album Carnaval.
James Klages posed the question and then has this to say on the subject:
Isn’t some of the demise of the cornet solos due to the transformation of the trumpet and cornet. They once had very distinctive sounds, but today, while the sounds are different, they have come much closer together?
To quote the Princes Bride “cornet solos are only “MOSTLY Dead.”
I still write and play them, as do my students. The Salvation army publishes new cornet solos about eight a year.
I see that rapid fall are the result of several factors.
1. Professional concert bands are extremely rare. Sousa is dead. the Goldman band is on hard times now.
2. Following Frederic Fennell, the wind ensemble literature shies away from the type of music that cornet soloists play. Colleges have adopted the programming philosophy of the wind ensemble. They seek to be a “higher level” of culture, not deigning to play transcriptions - or often music that is familiar, beautiful or exiting. The conductors at Eastman were jealous of the place and status of the orchestra and sought to one-up them with the elite - the refused to play down to the audience. In a relatively short time the audience went down from one of standing room only to that where the small wind ensemble out numbered the house. Recent years have somewhat reversed this trend. Sometimes a wind band concert is a pleasant musical
experience now..
3. The Twentieth Century experiment with musical complexity, and the relegation of beautiful melody and harmony to a secondary role undercut the entire function of the cornet in the Wind Band.
*It is now time for players to reclaim the role of composer - writing music that they enjoy to perform and listen (to.)
And Michael Stewart ripostes:
To me, this is the most telling and correct reasoning. And it is also the fault of MOST (certainly not all) of the typical cornet literature. Cornet solos are notoriously corny or “banal” in nature. How freakin’ many times do we have to listen to an inane Theme and Variations cornet solo that goes without any inspiration or musical character or thought - 1/8 note variation, triplet variation, 1/16 note variation, triplet 1/16s, etc….BLAAAAH!
Personally, the music written for wind ensembles mowadays (and throughout the previous century is FAR more entertaining, exciting, and musical than a concert of Sousa marches, cornet solos, and that ilk. As musicians, it’s our responsibility to uphold high levels of literature and to go beyond what is fun for the audience, or even ourselves. If we can decry popular musics (pop, rap, metal, country,etc) for pandering to the masses, then we have to hold ourselves to a similar standard and advance our craft - personally and
communally.
As a cornet player myself I love the grand cornet solos and would love to have the necessary technique to carry them off successfully. One day, who knows, I’ll be able to play Carnival of Venice or Napoli like Wynton. However, my belief is that music is for the purpose of entertaining people and in the concerts that I participate in, and have been to as a member of the audience, it is pieces that are melodic, easy to listen to and fun.
There’s no doubt in my mind that in these grand cornet solos there are some beautiful melodies and there are also some fun aspects to both for the listener and definitely for the player.
The most enjoyable “concert” I ever attended was a dinner/dance by the Lincoln Center Jazz Orchestra at the Barbican where the band played swing music. Was it corny? Possibly. Did we enjoy it? You bet!
When we’re out with the band our audience want to hear things like The Floral Dance, or The Lincolnshire Poacher whether the band like it or not and whether or not it’s corny.
All I can say is, let’s make music for people to listen to and enjoy.